Saturday, August 11, 2012

Chester-Upland School District better learn how to pick a fight

If the school district has their way, this photo will remain current

Weeks after signing the 'Save the School District' settlement with the State in Federal Court, the Chester-Upland School District has decided it will appeal the State's Charter Appeal Board decision to approve the Chester Charter School for the Arts in State Commonwealth Court.

Please reread that sentence again before moving on. Does it sound as crazy to you as it does to me? 


Let me try to break it down with statements from Daily Times articles to provide some background on this craziness. 

  • The Chester Fund for Education and the Arts applied to the Chester Upland board to open a charter after state funding cuts last year caused significant staff turnover at the Chester Upland School of the Arts.
  • After the Chester Upland board denied The Chester Fund a charter, The Chester Fund appealed to the Charter Appeal Board. That board overturned the district’s decision in July.
  • The Chester Upland School District and the Pennsylvania Department of Education signed a settlement agreement in federal court later in July.
  • The state agreed to pay the district’s outstanding vendor payments from the last school year and its unpaid charter payments. It also will compensate Chester Community Charter School for claims of underpayment in previous years, he said.
  • The Chester Upland School District filed an appeal of the Charter School Appeal Board’s decision with the Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court in hopes of overturning the Charter Appeal Board.
  • The district based its appeal on its lack of financial resources and the duplication of services...arguing that the appeal board’s decision to grant a charter violated the new distressed schools act.


I'll be the first to argue that charter schools has sucked a lot of money out of the Chester Upland School District. I don't believe the founding fathers of charter financials anticipated that charters would be so predominate, but there hasn't been much effort (or success) to change the original model. Now, charters are becoming a convenient direction for failing school districts to morph into.

On principle, I can't blame the school district for appealing the appeal boards approval of the Arts Charter. But, after selling your soul to the state with the settlement, do you really think you have a leg to stand on?

Why waste time, resources, and money trying to change the minds of the people who have already made up their minds regarding how this school district will be run. How can you expect to win an appeal? When the state reject the appeal, are you planning to appeal to the Feds? If so, how will that look when you just signed a settlement with the state in a federal court room?

These guys have demonstrated their commitment to charters when they agreed to pay all your outstanding bills, including those to the charters. That tells me that no matter how much you may think charters will break the district, there is someone in the state willing to pay that bill. 

Yes, the state has cut your legs out from under you, but that doesn't mean you should lock your doors and twiddle your fingers. 

Focus all your energy on the classrooms, the teachers, the students, the parents. That's where we need you. 

If you keep trying to fight the state, it only convinces us that you have your priorities all wrong. 

As quoted in 'The Black Industrialist', "When they put a gun to your head, you have to know when to give it up."

10 comments:

  1. fight till the wheels fall off

    ReplyDelete
  2. First it's important to remember that this is about the children, not about the districts inability to balance their budget. If parents believe that the charters are educating their children, then their tax dollars are being spent to educate their children the way they choose, not the way the school district chooses.

    The district is a business that needs to examine how to become competitive with charters,cybers, and private schools. Lawsuits are just making the lawyers rich.

    Here we are entering another school year and I still have not heard how CUSD is going to do a better job at educating children.

    I suggest that Chester Upland make AYP and graduate 95% of your senior class and then tell me you need more money or are able to handle more students.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with the comment, "What has CUSD done to convince the
    community that they can do a better job?" Proof is last year during
    financial ruins, the Board seem paralized into not doing anything
    while waiting for their Welfare check from the Governor. Sadly, I
    am not impressed with the newly elected Democrats who seem immobilized
    with the 5-4 vote. What strageties do they have to work around this
    inevitable evil? CUSD is too full of excuses while playing the blame
    game and children aren't being educated. Just Business as usual.

    Good luck to the new Charter School and the children who chose to go
    there.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. How can u be impress with them, when the majority (Republicans) will not let them do anytime.
      Every idea and public meeting they want to do has been BLOCK.

      Delete
  4. I'am a proud parent of Chester Community Charter School students and I very happy with the curriculum that the school provides our kids and the staff are very family oriented with the exception of some assistants in the school that are very ghetto I think they should do better jobs in hiring them . Besides that I support them 100%

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. CCCS....is a joke when the kids are done and transfer back into the CUSD they can not handle the public school curriculum. If your child has straight A at CCCS, if they good back to CUSD they will have Straight C's.
      Also, the staff is horrible...how come every year we see CCCS in the news that a staff member is abusing a student?.....CCCS, No Thanks.

      Delete
    2. Anonymous August 14, 2012 9:55Am.. Guess you were one of those straight A students from CCCS who had to attend CHS

      Delete
  5. the lawsuit was democrats idea to make the schools hole the state
    ran the school for 16 years ran it in the ground give use a chance
    to save it if not charter will run it with no oversight.

    ReplyDelete
  6. u sound like a fool, the board is made up of 5 Republicans and 4 Dems..the Republicans always overrule the Dems.
    get your facts straight

    ReplyDelete
  7. you wrong rep were on board 1year and did nothing

    ReplyDelete